I wasn't advocating for anyone to be cut, what I said was that McCarthy & Hogan have not performed so something had to happen.
I wasn't supportive of Walters & Pearce being sent back to Swans to sort themselves out as I thought there would be more negative influences on them away from Freo than at Freo, it turns out that both players had an intense desire to prove their detractors wrong, and they both did that.
What has happened to McCarthy & Hogan has nothing to do with their "quirky personalities" or anything else other than the fact that they have not performed to expectations. Until we know what discussions took place before the release of these 2 players, it is pretty pointless to apportion blame at any 1 individual, or even at a culture failure at the club. Michael Johnson, Walters, C Pearce, Ballas, Waterhouse, Bradley and plenty of others have brought "quirky" or "hard to handle" to the club, but have succeeded.