I offered plenty of reasoning for why SPS multitude of good games outweighs Logue's single good game. I'd take SPS ahead of Logue pretty easily. That doesn't mean I think Logue will be rubbish but he's still got a long way to go.
Maybe you should check back on
this post from last season Hypen, just to gain a refresher!
There's some disagreement between Morgan and I on how well we did out of that draft pick. My argument was in regards to paying over the top for Logue and co while putting at risk our ability to get quality talent in the door. As part of that and the deal with GWS, dropping away to pick 8 for Cammac was way overs when he was going nowhere but Freo and the same goes for Hamling who we can all agree was good value at that pick but still going nowhere else but Freo.