If we want to go with ruckmen and stick with the Hack's suggestion of home derby medals, we could have:
The 211 Hodor Medal
and the Toilet can go with the Cox Ball Badge.
Slapovich or Cox should go with nicknames too - The Flappy Slappo Medal has a really good ring to it. However, I just like the idea of Fyfe racking up a set of Collector Badges over the next decade: Flappy, Slappo, Voldemort, Chompy, Best-in-show, Corky, Pyro, Emblenuts, Flatline, Divey, Prince Charles, Hookfoot, Fatso, Notacluey. Toilet badges would emphasise the esteem with which they are really held.
Oh, the hilarity.