If you are referring to the final moments leading to Richmond'a last goal, RM, I'm not so sure you can put that much blame on Sutcliffe...if I recall properly, Fyfe took possession of the high loose ball, and his handball to Sutcliffe running by was a bit too hot and out of reach, and given that Sutcliffe was then subsequently surrounded by 3-4 Richmond players, the turnover was inevitable...
I'm not saying that he will be a world beater, but given the choice, I would still prefer Sutcliffe or Sheridan..