I was just thinking this the other day - had we managed to get the deal done and brought McCarthy over last year, would we still be in the same dire position that we are currently? I would like to think that we would have at least beaten Carlton, and possibly Gold Coast or North with some luck....but then again, would one player have made such a big difference, especially since it's turnovers and our crappy skills that has put us in this position? And knowing our luck this season, he would probably have done his ACL by now anyways...
