Drubbing,
using that logic nobody should be retained on our list. Pav, as a forward, missed 3 gettable shots. Mayne dropped marks all day and he's missed easy goals for 2 years. Johnno has dropped marks, Dawson refuses to take any. ditto Mundy, Fyfe, Neale.
Fact is, for all the criticism that he can't take marks, he took 8 yesterday and was one of our better performers. If the coach plays him down back, then he can't be criticised for not playing as a forward. Saying you'll only count marks if they are in the forward line is worse than dumb.
Give him the credit he deserves and just admit your comments were and are clearly wrong