Except that if he has a good year and Melbourne have a crap year as a team, he may try to move out earlier. This would mean we would have to give up a couple of reasonable players and our first round draft pick. He is definitely worth it as is McCarthy. Problem is who do we go for and if Tab's comes good and Hannath starts to hit his straps (remember these are only young guys who have not really played a lot of football) does this mean the urgency to get one or both of those guys is not so great. Do we try to get Hooker from Essendon instead? ( I have always been fond of a good hooker).