That's ridiculous Gumnut, You're going to base anyone's worth on one game of the season. So how did Sydney do as well as they did with all those "losers"?
So if you're going to judge it like that, nobody would want Heeney, Gulden, Papley, Rampe, Rowbottom, Blakey, in fact anybody as they didn't have a winner all day.
I will say though that I'm glad we haven't persevered with the idea of getting McDonald as he's doing very little all year, unlike Warner who without, Sydney wouldn't have got as far as they did.