True, I'm not sure how many deals I'd get done in their shoes but I'd be privy to a lot more information to make that decision!
I tend to rate draft picks higher than a lot of people who don't see the kids and only see what is established in the AFL. I also don't like the thought process that due to having other second round picks, it's ok to give up this one. Other picks shouldn't make a difference whatsoever and this deal should be looked at on it's own merits.
That second round pick was very valuable to us and the pies third round pick is likely to be a pick in the 50's where as the Saints pick we gave away is more likely in the early 20's. That's a huge gulf in points and players available. I don't think Aish is worth that gulf when we have the likes of Ryan, Wilson, Hughes, Blakely, Cerra, S Hill, Duman, Carter and a tonne more as options off half back. Is he really any better than what we have available?
