I'm conflicted about Erasmus because on the one hand he's been dealt a rough hand with limited opportunities, and on the other hand I honestly don't think he's taken his chances they've presented themselves.
It's about this age that players like him start to make an impact. Hopefully 2025 will be a big year for him. If it's not, then it's not going to happen for him at Freo.
As for Brodie, I'm glad he's staying. He became a fringe player at Gold Coast and now Freo, so I'm not sure there's many other options available to him other than to stay, put in the hard yards at Peel, and be ready to take an opportunity in the team when if it presents itself.