For what it's worth, I'm pretty happy with the approach the club has taken. I don't really carry a wallet anymore, so I'm happy to have the digital membership card. I've never understood why people wear the lanyards (perhaps they also don't carry wallets?), but I've thrown out about 30 membership lanyards in my time and never actually worn one, so that seems a bit wasteful.
It seems to me that giving members a team store voucher allows members to buy things they actually want. Perhaps one of the options should be that you can use that voucher towards printing up a mock membership card and getting a lanyard?
I do miss the fixture magnet, but given current circumstances I can understand why you wouldn't put a fixture in print.
The decision to print a matte finish sticker is questionable, but I'm willing to give it a season to see how it goes. I like that at least it is more purple this year.