Martin Pike played on the wing in Brisbane's three peats Mont.
Sometimes you're lucky to be part of a great team with a great coach, sometimes you're dead unlucky to spend your career at a dud side.
David Hale, Ben Stratton, Brian Lake all played in Hawthorn's last three premierships. Does that make them among the great players and better than others that missed playing at Hawthorn? In fact Spangher played in two of them ffs.
Never denied that Hill isn't very good, just that Kelly is more valuable to a side. He basically does everything that Hill can, but can also play inside, is a better kick and mark and hits the scoreboard more often.
Hill would have it over Kelly in the amount of run and carry he can bring to a game though.