I would say we have a great chance at a straight swap, Kelly 25 out of contract wants to come home, Hill 26 two years to run on his contract wants to go to Melbourne.
If Geelong play hard ball and ask for too much, whats to stop Kelly from just walking into the pre season draft and then Geelong miss out all together, the Melbourne media will all talk about how he'll be snapped up by one of the low clubs on the ladder but when has any player that went to the pre season draft with a preferred team not got to the team or state they wanted.
Hill will have to play ball with what we say or play out his contract, Geelong refused to trade Kelly when they had all the cards last year now they'll have to settle for what they can get.
Brad Hill for Tim Kelly should be a straight swap.
Now what can we get for Ed Langdon, factoring in he's out of contract but better than Weller.