If one allows for some logic, how the heck can Freo end up minor premiers in 2015, then in 2016, 8 games in, be 0-8 and therefore recruiting (& virtually every aspect of the Fremantle Football club) must be blamed. As far as I'm aware, the major difference between the end of 2015 and the start of 2016 is Freo players are another 6 months older.
Rarely am I seeing any of the critical opinions even mentioning Fremantle's injuries.
I know Freo are a no excuses club, but surely injuries to 211, Fyfe, and others are at least one reasonable explanation rather than an excuse. I also know other clubs also have some injuries, but I'm not aware of any clubs that have any sort of injuries equivalent to Freo's currently sidelined A graders and which of those teams are still performing well?
I think many critics enjoy any opportunity to voice their opinion and they feel the 0-8 win loss justifies their critical analysis.
But ... 6 of Freo's 8 losses have so far been against top 8 teams. 5 of those 6 were also Away games.
(NB: As I recently posted, the Slime, since Round 1 2015, have won only 1 of their last 8 games away against top 8 teams).
The one home game that Freo lost vs a top8, was against GWS (with Freo missing 211, Fyfe, Johnno and playing many inexperienced youngsters). GWS smashed the Hawks only the week before and after watching some of that game, I backed GWS for premiers 2016.
So that leaves, in my mind, two bad losses to Gold Coast and Carlton. Freo had the major injuries against Carlton, statistically should have won the game. There was no injuries against Gold Coast, and again, on stats, Freo performed quite well, but in practice, got smashed due to costly opposition scoring from stoppages and turnovers. Roly admits the midfield defensive game was altered leading to many of those problems in that game.
So what I do know is, Freo are now 0-8 and still with major injuries to several A graders. That means 2016 is done.
My opinion is, I'm blaming injuries, a tougher start to the draw than first perceived and some early season new game plan tweaks to score more which actually made Freo's defence worse.
Most of the current critical opinions I'm reading are very much over the top and basing most of their arguments on the current 0-8 win loss record for 2016 (while comfortably ignoring what just happened in 2015).