There has been more hypocritical crap on this post than one of Tony Abbott's speeches, not to mention oodles of incorrect information. A bit of sanity form Hypen in bringing up Clive and lets face it, sanity and Clive in the same sentence is not common.
How you can declare Apeness no good after 2 injury plagued years of very little football beggars belief. You might end up being correct, but not from any knowledge. Sh$%house blind luck more like. Timmeh, I think you'll find Treloar was out of contract and they basically couldn't give him what he was worth after signing up the likes of Cameron, Shiel and keeping up the Scully payments.
If we get McCarthy great. If we don't, I'm not sure you can blame anyone for sticking to their guns by either keeping a conracted player (GWS), not wanting to pay overs (us) or wanting to come home (CM). If he stays, I hope he continues to play well and be good for us in a couple of years.